Peer Song Reviews From Broadjam.com
Broadjam Artist: Hartmut OberdieckSong: stardust memoriesReviewer: Kate CarpenterPositive Comments: Interesting instrumental piece. Expertly put together and mixed. So many sounds to hear. Nice percussion. I like the guitars. Great energy throughou…
Broadjam Artist: Hartmut Oberdieck
Song: stardust memories
Reviewer: Kate Carpenter
Positive Comments: Interesting instrumental piece. Expertly put together and mixed. So many sounds to hear. Nice percussion. I like the guitars. Great energy throughout. Nothing seems out of place here. Definitely nothing boring here. Watch out for the spaceships zooming by at the end. Nicely done!
Constructive Comments: I’m sure there’s a commercial market for this kind of piece…but don’t ask me where.
Broadjam Artist: Simpson-Mancine ProductionsSong: Line in the SandReviewer: Kate CarpenterPositive Comments: This appears to be a protest poem put to music. Or perhaps it’s a poem about protesters put to music. The imagery is excellent. The presenta…
Broadjam Artist: Simpson-Mancine Productions
Song: Line in the Sand
Reviewer: Kate Carpenter
Positive Comments: This appears to be a protest poem put to music. Or perhaps it’s a poem about protesters put to music. The imagery is excellent. The presentation is a bit cerebral it’s a song to make the listener think. Where have we been? Where are we headed? Have we made any progress at all? Not a real message of hope here…just a reality check, which, by the way is sonically very well put together. I like the percussive bass underlay and the guitars on top.
Constructive Comments: This song suffers from the lack of a chorus. I could understand most of the words, but when you started ramping it up, the vocals (too many effects? Faulty mix?) got muddied a bit. Thanks for posting the lyrics. It helped me to see the mastery of your poetry. The last verse is particularly compelling.
Broadjam Artist: Mitch SiegalSong: Takers and FoolsReviewer: MGBPositive Comments: Very nicely arranged and performed piece with very thoughtful and intelligent lyrics. Constructive Comments: Good tune.
Broadjam Artist: Mitch Siegal
Song: Takers and Fools
Reviewer: MGB
Positive Comments: Very nicely arranged and performed piece with very thoughtful and intelligent lyrics.
Constructive Comments: Good tune.
Broadjam Artist: Hartmut OberdieckSong: special fieldReviewer: MGBPositive Comments: Very well played and well arranged piece. Right off the bat, you get Mark Knopfler vibes and it continues throughout. Constructive Comments: Good work!
Broadjam Artist: Hartmut Oberdieck
Song: special field
Reviewer: MGB
Positive Comments: Very well played and well arranged piece. Right off the bat, you get Mark Knopfler vibes and it continues throughout.
Constructive Comments: Good work!
Broadjam Artist: B.StillSong: SUMTHIN’ PRETTY SADReviewer: John WalradtPositive Comments: I think David Lanz would enjoy this. The melody has several interesting sections and is very pleasant, also builds excitement in carefully selected places. Beauti…
Broadjam Artist: B.Still
Song: SUMTHIN’ PRETTY SAD
Reviewer: John Walradt
Positive Comments: I think David Lanz would enjoy this. The melody has several interesting sections and is very pleasant, also builds excitement in carefully selected places. Beautiful playing and studio work. It does just what a lovely New Age piece should do.
Constructive Comments: Order dinner from your favorite restaurant, celebrate and enjoy yourself.
Broadjam Artist: Sam CooperSong: FORGIVENESSReviewer: Margie & Art CoreyPositive Comments: This sounds like Randy Newman, how cool is that?? Great job, could be in a romantic comedy…….Super Job.This is just a really fun tune…….Constructive Comm…
Broadjam Artist: Sam Cooper
Song: FORGIVENESS
Reviewer: Margie & Art Corey
Positive Comments: This sounds like Randy Newman, how cool is that?? Great job, could be in a romantic comedy…….Super Job.This is just a really fun tune…….
Constructive Comments: Nothing to add….just terrific songwriting!!!
Broadjam Artist: Jeff AshbakerSong: Love ’emReviewer: Margie & Art CoreyPositive Comments: This has a really Killer Country sound, nice lead vocal too. The instrumentation is perfect for the tune! It’s well recorded and probably universally true in the…
Broadjam Artist: Jeff Ashbaker
Song: Love ’em
Reviewer: Margie & Art Corey
Positive Comments: This has a really Killer Country sound, nice lead vocal too. The instrumentation is perfect for the tune! It’s well recorded and probably universally true in theme!
Constructive Comments: Have no comments or suggestions
Broadjam Artist: Barry OsbournSong: Anna LeeReviewer: Jeff AshbakerPositive Comments: It has a great haunting feel to it and a original sound. Particularly like the 2 vocals at certain points in the song.Constructive Comments: Vocal could maybe be up f…
Broadjam Artist: Barry Osbourn
Song: Anna Lee
Reviewer: Jeff Ashbaker
Positive Comments: It has a great haunting feel to it and a original sound. Particularly like the 2 vocals at certain points in the song.
Constructive Comments: Vocal could maybe be up front a little more?
Broadjam Artist: Margie & Art CoreySong: Second Chance II Coreys B. SwadeReviewer: Jeff AshbakerPositive Comments: Good solid current sounding country with an extra kick via the great Sax solo.Constructive Comments: Maybe more strait Country than Blues?
Broadjam Artist: Margie & Art Corey
Song: Second Chance II Coreys B. Swade
Reviewer: Jeff Ashbaker
Positive Comments: Good solid current sounding country with an extra kick via the great Sax solo.
Constructive Comments: Maybe more strait Country than Blues?
Broadjam Artist: MGBSong: COLD LONELY HOUSEReviewer: David JamesPositive Comments: Excellent lyrics with a strong theme and story. Great vocal. The singer really sells the song and good use of harmonies, which are in just the right places. Lovely guita…
Broadjam Artist: MGB
Song: COLD LONELY HOUSE
Reviewer: David James
Positive Comments: Excellent lyrics with a strong theme and story. Great vocal. The singer really sells the song and good use of harmonies, which are in just the right places. Lovely guitars. I like the way the instruments are pulled back at 3.43 that is a nice touch. The sound quality is excellent. The song is worthy of The Eagles.
Constructive Comments: I’ve marked down the quality of the arrangement for one reason only and that is I think the song is just a tad slow. Even an extra 5 or 10 BPM might give the song an extra shot of dynamism. That said, it is really a strong piece of work. Worth pitching for the relevant opportunities.