Broadjam Artist: Ante NovaselicSong: Play YahReviewer: Jeff RobertsPositive Comments: This is big, badass tune. Love the Black Hole Sun guitar tone on the intro. There’s a really fat tone on the bass and it grooves tightly with the drums whacking tot…

Broadjam Artist: Ante Novaselic
Song: Play Yah
Reviewer: Jeff Roberts
Positive Comments: This is big, badass tune. Love the Black Hole Sun guitar tone on the intro. There’s a really fat tone on the bass and it grooves tightly with the drums whacking totally in the pocket with that tasty just so little behind the beat snare. It’s a Punk meets Ska feel which makes it like a tune out of the UK except clearly American vocals. “rules are made to be broken” is a great moment of phrasing and vocal performance. That horn break on the bridge is superbly arranged and it really suits the tune. Very sexy female vocals. As a reference I’d point to Fitz and the Tantrums.
Constructive Comments: This is a tough one to critique because I think this is really good and could be on contemporary radio but it’s not quite there yet (IMO of course) The vocal multitracking / wide panning is really cool I think you’re overdoing it on the verses. The side voices are a bit out of tune, and there’s a weird mix because it’s not true double tracking and it’s not a chorus of different voices either. I think you’ve got a deliberate detuning effect there, and it’s too much. Do the multi/wide pan on key phrases rather than everything.On the chorus (which is a strong hook) I think you need more lyrical content. An answering line to “hey ya I’m gonna play ya” eg “rip your clothes off and lay ya” / “take a revenge porn video and shame ya” –just joking but some kinda of B line to the A. By itself I don’t think the current line is enough even though it’s great hook.On second thought I think the horns are working really well on the bridge, and those aren’t samples would like to hear the brass with more guts there. As much as I love the guitar intro I don’t think it fits the overall Ska feel that you have, and it sets up the wrong expectations for the song. I’d kick in with the beat and the horns that follow the guitar intro.On the chorus I think the arrangement is a little empty when it needs bigger. I think you need more instrument boost in the mix there and maybe bring backing harmony vocals in more with you on main line although the meandering parts currently sound good tune.This is good stuff GOOD LUCK!!